Transfer disputes

Nevertoomuchhockey · Post by **Nevertoomuchhockey** » Mon Nov 24, 2014 9:28 pm

Bluewhitefan wrote:
WestMetro wrote:Weird, since there are some transfer moves elsewhere this year that are much more gray than this one.

If doesn't get resolved, suspect JM will go back to Omaha rather than play JV
I'm not sure we know how gray this one is or isn't. If the family claimed to have moved and then didn't, but rented an empty apartment, shame on them for trying to skirt the rules. If the administration, including Giles, didn't fully research the eligibility before tryouts, shame on them. Face meet egg.

Sounds like a certain family up hinterland way...

hockey_is_a_choice · Post by **hockey_is_a_choice** » Mon Nov 24, 2014 9:59 pm

Blah, blah, you asked whether I was an attorney and referred to me as a moron. Two words: DENNY CRANE!

http://youtu.be/iXuQ5c9E4eQ

observer · Post by **observer** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 7:38 am

Listen, Edina coaches, players and parents really don't like transfers. And, don't need them.

They got what they wanted by stating it was a sticky add and so for team eligibility questions with the MSHSL we'll skip the opportunity to add this player. Perfect. Done.

Bluewhitefan · Post by **Bluewhitefan** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 8:08 am

observer wrote:Listen, Edina coaches, players and parents really don't like transfers. And, don't need them.

Unless they're in the top 6 forwards or top 4 D.

almostashappy · Post by **almostashappy** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 8:23 am

Bluewhitefan wrote:
observer wrote:Listen, Edina coaches, players and parents really don't like transfers. And, don't need them.
Unless they're in the top 6 forwards or top 4 D.

Yeah, I caught that too. Don't remember hearing any cakey complaints when a different kid from Eagan "transferred" to Edina after spending one year at a private school and a second year outside of the MSHSL.

minnscout · Post by **minnscout** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 10:07 am

JM is top 4 D

thespellchecker · Post by **thespellchecker** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 10:39 am

If the boy has siblings and they attend Edina schools as well due to the family move, there should not be a issue.

Bluewhitefan · Post by **Bluewhitefan** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 12:24 pm

minnscout wrote:JM is top 4 D

Possibly, but stated a bit too matter of fact. Very much open for debate.

Nuts&Bolts · Post by **Nuts&Bolts** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 2:07 pm

Burnsville's chances at a section title may have fizzled. Can you imagine the noise and lawsuits in Edina had the AD permitted an ineligible transfer to play that disqualified the cake from the post season and a run at another title?

Froggy Richards · Post by **Froggy Richards** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 2:18 pm

thespellchecker wrote:If the boy has siblings and they attend Edina schools as well due to the family move, there should not be a issue.

That makes a lot of sense, if you don't think about it.

Bluewhitefan · Post by **Bluewhitefan** » Tue Nov 25, 2014 2:56 pm

Froggy Richards wrote:
thespellchecker wrote:If the boy has siblings and they attend Edina schools as well due to the family move, there should not be a issue.
That makes a lot of sense, if you don't think about it.

Or, it makes no sense, if you do think about it.

blueblood · Post by **blueblood** » Wed Nov 26, 2014 9:49 pm

even if the player in question has siblings that attend Edina schools, that doesn't necessarily make him eligible to play varsity sports.

Whiner33 · Post by **Whiner33** » Wed Nov 26, 2014 10:44 pm

The thread has four pages of nonsense. Don't think Edina needs the kid!

End of story!!

Monster hockey · Post by **Monster hockey** » Thu Nov 27, 2014 6:09 am

Whiner33 wrote:The thread has four pages of nonsense. Don't think Edina needs the kid!

End of story!!

If Edina didn't need JM then why did he make the varsity team? Why did the kid from JV who took JMs spot hardly get any playing time? It must be because Edina doesn't need him... Each individual player has a key spot on the team. Clearly the coach picked his team as he needed it from the get go. I am positive the coach knows best. If he wanted different players he would have chose them. Let's let the coach decide what Edina needs!!!!
End of story!!!!!

Monster hockey · Post by **Monster hockey** » Thu Nov 27, 2014 6:36 am

observer wrote:Listen, Edina coaches, players and parents really don't like transfers. And, don't need them.

They got what they wanted by stating it was a sticky add and so for team eligibility questions with the MSHSL we'll skip the opportunity to add this player. Perfect. Done.

Let's enlighten you.... Edina parents do not like transfers!!! Transfers take their kids spot. Edina coaches who want to win love transfers!!!!!

DONE!

Whiner33 · Post by **Whiner33** » Thu Nov 27, 2014 7:35 am

Monster hockey wrote:
Whiner33 wrote:The thread has four pages of nonsense. Don't think Edina needs the kid!

End of story!!

If Edina didn't need JM then why did he make the varsity team? Why did the kid from JV who took JMs spot hardly get any playing time? It must be because Edina doesn't need him... Each individual player has a key spot on the team. Clearly the coach picked his team as he needed it from the get go. I am positive the coach knows best. If he wanted different players he would have chose them. Let's let the coach decide what Edina needs!!!!
End of story!!!!!

Ok ok ok....

Let's get Giles on line one.....

The parents on line two....

The whopper 2 on line three...

The AD on line four....

Then monster hockey on line five....

Let's hammer this big problem out then!!!

As the world turns continues...

Monster hockey · Post by **Monster hockey** » Thu Nov 27, 2014 8:26 am

Whiner33 wrote:
Monster hockey wrote:
Whiner33 wrote:The thread has four pages of nonsense. Don't think Edina needs the kid!

End of story!!

If Edina didn't need JM then why did he make the varsity team? Why did the kid from JV who took JMs spot hardly get any playing time? It must be because Edina doesn't need him... Each individual player has a key spot on the team. Clearly the coach picked his team as he needed it from the get go. I am positive the coach knows best. If he wanted different players he would have chose them. Let's let the coach decide what Edina needs!!!!
End of story!!!!!
Ok ok ok....

Let's get Giles on line one.....

The parents on line two....

The whopper 2 on line three...

The AD on line four....

Then monster hockey on line five....

Let's hammer this big problem out then!!!

As the world turns continues...

Oh ok whiner... User name very fitting!!

Whiner33 · Post by **Whiner33** » Thu Nov 27, 2014 8:44 am

Monster hockey wrote:
Whiner33 wrote:
Monster hockey wrote:

If Edina didn't need JM then why did he make the varsity team? Why did the kid from JV who took JMs spot hardly get any playing time? It must be because Edina doesn't need him... Each individual player has a key spot on the team. Clearly the coach picked his team as he needed it from the get go. I am positive the coach knows best. If he wanted different players he would have chose them. Let's let the coach decide what Edina needs!!!!
End of story!!!!!
Ok ok ok....

Let's get Giles on line one.....

The parents on line two....

The whopper 2 on line three...

The AD on line four....

Then monster hockey on line five....

Let's hammer this big problem out then!!!

As the world turns continues...

Oh ok whiner... User name very fitting!!

Hope the big monster from the Latino mafia isn't on his way yikes!!

green4 · Post by **green4** » Thu Nov 27, 2014 11:43 pm

Monster hockey wrote:
Whiner33 wrote:The thread has four pages of nonsense. Don't think Edina needs the kid!

End of story!!

Why did the kid from JV who took JMs spot hardly get any playing time?

The kid who took his spot has 3 points already. I think he will do just fine.

sinbin · Post by **sinbin** » Fri Nov 28, 2014 2:24 pm

Entertaining stuff, . . . very sad, but still entertaining.

notTONIGHT · Post by **notTONIGHT** » Sat Nov 29, 2014 12:47 pm

So is he headed back?

Monster hockey · Post by **Monster hockey** » Sat Nov 29, 2014 2:18 pm

green4 wrote:
Monster hockey wrote:
Whiner33 wrote:The thread has four pages of nonsense. Don't think Edina needs the kid!

End of story!!

Why did the kid from JV who took JMs spot hardly get any playing time?
The kid who took his spot has 3 points already. I think he will do just fine.[/

Hopefully "just fine" will be enough. Playing for a team as an after though can't be very fun. I know I wouldn't want to be second choice. Hopefully for the kids sake he won't even realize. I bet the kids parents were furious when JM took his spot.

almostashappy · Post by **almostashappy** » Sun Nov 30, 2014 10:55 am

Monster hockey wrote: Hopefully "just fine" will be enough. Playing for a team as an after though can't be very fun. I know I wouldn't want to be second choice. Hopefully for the kids sake he won't even realize. I bet the kids parents were furious when JM took his spot.

I'm sure that the parents were furious, and the "after thought" kid was disappointed. But as far as I know, any decision on who is makes varsity and who is JV doesn't really have to be made until just before Sections start.

On the teams that my kid played on, there was always some movement up/down between Varsity/JV during the season, depending on who was playing well/not well and who gets injured. Being a bubble kid who didn't "make" the Varsity team at the start of the season wasn't a death sentence. Sometimes, it was just the kick in the butt that a kid needed to play closer to his potential (so that after a lot of hard work and a few 5:30am practices he was promoted by Christmas).

But maybe mileage varies on the other side of the River, and some rosters are set into stone in November?

Post by **karl(east)** » Thu Dec 04, 2014 11:47 am

Duluth East junior Luke Dow has been ruled eligible by the MSHSL and can suit up for the Hounds' varsity squad tonight. Good news for DE, obviously, as their offense will benefit from a dynamic player like him.

Traxler · Post by **Traxler** » Thu Dec 04, 2014 12:37 pm

Has Jared Mickelson appealed his eligibility ruling? Can he even if it was a determination of ineligibility by the Edina AD as reported in this thread?

HighSchoolHockeyForums.com

Transfer disputes

spellchecker

Re: spellchecker

Re: spellchecker

Re: spellchecker

Re: spellchecker

Re: spellchecker

Re: spellchecker

Re: spellchecker

Re: spellchecker