New BAA playoff rules--new members in D6
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
New BAA playoff rules--new members in D6
Has anyone else heard that minnesota hockey has done away with all district and regional playoffs for BAA, and they are seeding top teams for state.
Make matters worse, the powers that be are moving Wayzata, Maple Grove, and Owatonna BAA into D 6 this year. So D6 BAA will look like this--EP, Edina, Prior Lake, Minnetonka, Wayzata, Maple Grove, Bloomington Jefferson, CCHA, and Owatonna. Only 4 can make it out of that district. Makes sense to me Minnesota Hockey. Why don't you throw Elk River and Stillwater in just for good measure.
Make matters worse, the powers that be are moving Wayzata, Maple Grove, and Owatonna BAA into D 6 this year. So D6 BAA will look like this--EP, Edina, Prior Lake, Minnetonka, Wayzata, Maple Grove, Bloomington Jefferson, CCHA, and Owatonna. Only 4 can make it out of that district. Makes sense to me Minnesota Hockey. Why don't you throw Elk River and Stillwater in just for good measure.
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Thu Aug 15, 2013 10:21 am
They should force D2 and D10 to do the same...would make for a few good AA leagues. D2 has only 4 designated AA teams (FL, WBL, Stillwater, Roseville)...with MV and Tartan opting down. They should play with the A teams if they want. Sounds like Andover wants to opt down in Bantams (at least that was mentioned on the forum somewhere) which leaves Centennial, ER, Blaine...who else? Anoka? CP? Others doing AA or not?
I know they tried to get this done but the D2 members voted it down hmmm....
I know they tried to get this done but the D2 members voted it down hmmm....
So let's examine the absurdity of this: D6 will now have 10 AA teams (gorilla you forgot Burnsville). D8 looks like 8 teams, D10 4-6 (is CP going AA?. Is Irondale and SF co-oping again?), D2 four teams, D5 four teams. And you're gonna pull 23 teams from those 30-32 (assume Rochester gets a flyer out of D9 and the north teams are locked). I'm just wondering... disregard the idea that OMG and Wayzata are powerhouses... how can you take only four teams out of ten? To be fair, I'd think it should be seven (23/32 = 70%). Six from D8, 3-4 form D10 and 3 from D2 & D5.
That is if you must sway from the original open seeding process MH published in July.... http://www.minnesotahockey.org/news_art ... _id=710946
I mean, that actually made some sense. Good to see MH changing directions at the 11th hour!
That is if you must sway from the original open seeding process MH published in July.... http://www.minnesotahockey.org/news_art ... _id=710946
I mean, that actually made some sense. Good to see MH changing directions at the 11th hour!
-
- Posts: 149
- Joined: Mon Dec 01, 2008 11:48 am
-
- Posts: 290
- Joined: Fri Nov 12, 2010 11:05 am
- Location: Centerville
All AA D2 associations were for but Roseville, and they were the deciding vote. (Single A teams were against it as well)[/quote]surehockey wrote:[I know they tried to get this done but the D2 members voted it down hmmm....
I thought voting was done by a weighted vote based on association size ? if Roseville was the only one voting no? there should have been another 7 - 9 teams voting Yes ? had to be other factors then unless they were looking for 100% support ?
-
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Thu Aug 15, 2013 10:21 am
But, isnt it the case where the teams are going to be ranked 1-24 going into the Region tournaments and then broken up according to where they were seeded and then 2 seeds from each Region will go to the State tournament? So, for argument's sake, Edina is ranked as the top seed out of D6 at the BAA level and Eden Prairie is ranked #2 and then maybe Wayzata is ranked #3. Is it not the case then that Edina would go to the South Region, EP to the East and Wayzata to the West?
-
- Posts: 1109
- Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2011 12:20 pm
Here is what we learned that came out of D6 on Monday night. We also spoke to MNH yesterday and there are no plans to change this year's Regional format.
http://www.youthhockeyhub.com/news-out-of-d6/
http://www.youthhockeyhub.com/news-out-of-d6/
gorilla: unless the selection process has changed, i don't see in the MNHockey regulations anything about limiting the number of teams one district can have in the region tournaments. The North is doing its own Region with Ds 11, 12, 15 & 16. Each North District will send 2 teams to its 8-team Region. The other three Regions will be comprised of the top-24 teams from Ds 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, & 10, with each of the 24 seeds being assigned to a certain Region (#1 in South, #2 East, #3 West, etc, etc). So, hypothetically, if the District Directors and Bantam AA coaches, who are doing the selecting feel that 7 of the top-24 teams are in D6, then so be it. The only stipulation is that each District's #1 seed is guaranteed a spot in the top-24. Again, this is how i understand it unless the process has been changed.
-
- Posts: 1109
- Joined: Mon Nov 28, 2011 12:20 pm
Got a DM this am that my story may have a flaw or two on Rochester. He says Rochester is fielding a AA team at both Bantam AA and PeeWee AA.
I have a call into Tom C, the DD at D9.
In other words, there is more to this story.
Deep Breath is right. There has not been a change in the system for Regions that was approved in June.
I have a call into Tom C, the DD at D9.
In other words, there is more to this story.
Deep Breath is right. There has not been a change in the system for Regions that was approved in June.