Must be a written rule you cannot allow 3 players from the same team to be nominated for Mr. Hockey (TJ Moore) or if, your last name is Moore (Meirs and TJ). Glance at there regular season schedule vs. some of these other nominee's and they definitely deserve to be recognizedGPGT wrote:The Exiled One wrote:Good list, I think. Possible snubs include Max Coatta, Meirs Moore, Matt Colford, and Travis Koepke. Others?
This
MR HOCKEY 2013
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
-
- Posts: 265
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 2:53 pm
-
- Posts: 514
- Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2008 3:40 pm
f
I'm surprised not one kid from Duluth East, they might be the best team in the state when this thing is over and they don't have any Seniors worthy of nomination?
I think Jake Guentzel would have given Besse the biggest run for his $ if he stuck around. (I would almost guarantee Besse wins it-especially after his tourney performance last year), although I think Vanelli is the BEST HS player in MN this year and of all the seniors I think he will have the most post HS success.
-
- Posts: 6480
- Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 9:03 pm
- Contact:
Re: f
While this East team does not have as much front-end talent as the past few, I was disappointed that Meirs Moore did not make the list. He's having a huge season for the Hounds, and has really improved the defensive side of his game. (His puck-moving skills were never in question.)Tenoverpar wrote:I'm surprised not one kid from Duluth East, they might be the best team in the state when this thing is over and they don't have any Seniors worthy of nomination?
However, NHL scouts do play an important role in the voting for this award, and 5'9" defensemen will, unfortunately, struggle to garner much attention, no matter how well they run a team's power play. It is what it is.
I would agree with all of this. Often Mr. Hockey goes to the player who is the best pro prospect, but Besse's HS achievements have been so overwhelming that he's hard to pass up. And I think that is the right call, as the award should be based primarily on what players have done, and not what they might do in the future.Sats81 wrote:I think Jake Guentzel would have given Besse the biggest run for his $ if he stuck around. (I would almost guarantee Besse wins it-especially after his tourney performance last year), although I think Vanelli is the BEST HS player in MN this year and of all the seniors I think he will have the most post HS success.
Re: f
So if its based on what they have done, how is bischoff on there with only 6 goals thus far, and moore, who is the leader on a top team in the state and is having a great season? its the best high school player in the state, not the kid with the most potential. not that it matters because besse is going to winkarl(east) wrote:While this East team does not have as much front-end talent as the past few, I was disappointed that Meirs Moore did not make the list. He's having a huge season for the Hounds, and has really improved the defensive side of his game. (His puck-moving skills were never in question.)Tenoverpar wrote:I'm surprised not one kid from Duluth East, they might be the best team in the state when this thing is over and they don't have any Seniors worthy of nomination?
However, NHL scouts do play an important role in the voting for this award, and 5'9" defensemen will, unfortunately, struggle to garner much attention, no matter how well they run a team's power play. It is what it is.
I would agree with all of this. Often Mr. Hockey goes to the player who is the best pro prospect, but Besse's HS achievements have been so overwhelming that he's hard to pass up. And I think that is the right call, as the award should be based primarily on what players have done, and not what they might do in the future.Sats81 wrote:I think Jake Guentzel would have given Besse the biggest run for his $ if he stuck around. (I would almost guarantee Besse wins it-especially after his tourney performance last year), although I think Vanelli is the BEST HS player in MN this year and of all the seniors I think he will have the most post HS success.
-
- Posts: 615
- Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2011 10:25 pm
- Location: G.R.
Re: f
If you ask the NHL scouts and D1 coaches that made the list maybe they can tell you. They must have seen something about his play they liked. I agree that Moore was a big snub though, great player.Hounds19 wrote:So if its based on what they have done, how is bischoff on there with only 6 goals thus far, and moore, who is the leader on a top team in the state and is having a great season? its the best high school player in the state, not the kid with the most potential. not that it matters because besse is going to winkarl(east) wrote:While this East team does not have as much front-end talent as the past few, I was disappointed that Meirs Moore did not make the list. He's having a huge season for the Hounds, and has really improved the defensive side of his game. (His puck-moving skills were never in question.)Tenoverpar wrote:I'm surprised not one kid from Duluth East, they might be the best team in the state when this thing is over and they don't have any Seniors worthy of nomination?
However, NHL scouts do play an important role in the voting for this award, and 5'9" defensemen will, unfortunately, struggle to garner much attention, no matter how well they run a team's power play. It is what it is.
I would agree with all of this. Often Mr. Hockey goes to the player who is the best pro prospect, but Besse's HS achievements have been so overwhelming that he's hard to pass up. And I think that is the right call, as the award should be based primarily on what players have done, and not what they might do in the future.Sats81 wrote:I think Jake Guentzel would have given Besse the biggest run for his $ if he stuck around. (I would almost guarantee Besse wins it-especially after his tourney performance last year), although I think Vanelli is the BEST HS player in MN this year and of all the seniors I think he will have the most post HS success.
Thunderhawk Fanatic!!
-
- Posts: 6480
- Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 9:03 pm
- Contact:
Re: f
That's the thing...it isn't really based on what they've done, unless what they've done is so overwhelmingly impressive that it cant be ignored (ie. Besse). Potential does matter for the award. Personally, I don't like this, as it leads to nominations for players like Bischoff or Mark Alt a few years back, who both missed half the season with an injury. I don't want to take anything away from those players, as they are both very talented and had/have very bright futures, but when players like that get nominated, what are we really rewarding?Hounds19 wrote:So if its based on what they have done, how is bischoff on there with only 6 goals thus far, and moore, who is the leader on a top team in the state and is having a great season? its the best high school player in the state, not the kid with the most potential. not that it matters because besse is going to win
-
- Posts: 1102
- Joined: Wed Jan 17, 2007 2:07 pm
-
- Posts: 3696
- Joined: Wed Feb 25, 2009 6:37 pm
-
- Posts: 7260
- Joined: Tue Nov 07, 2006 10:28 pm
I'm very curious how he'll fit in with the Badgers' "rope-a-dope" defensive-oriented system. With a minimum of four games per year vs. the Gophers we'll get ample opportunity to see how he progresses.Slap Shot wrote:Congrats to Besse. I hope he has fun playing for a program that loves scoring 2 goals a game.