Class A tournament seeds
Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)
-
- Posts: 666
- Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 1:40 pm
Class A tournament seeds
Now that the tournament is jsut about set, how will the seeds end up. I think it will end up like this.
1. Little Falls
2. SCC
3. Breck
4. Warroad
1. Little Falls
2. SCC
3. Breck
4. Warroad
-
- Posts: 107
- Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2008 11:41 am
Re: Class A tournament seeds
WOW Warroad has to be pretty happy right about now.warriors41 wrote:Now that the tournament is jsut about set, how will the seeds end up. I think it will end up like this.
1. Little Falls
2. SCC
3. Breck
4. Warroad
-
- Posts: 666
- Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 1:40 pm
Re: Class A tournament seeds
I would imagine soSCSUHOCKEYFAN15 wrote:WOW Warroad has to be pretty happy right about now.warriors41 wrote:Now that the tournament is jsut about set, how will the seeds end up. I think it will end up like this.
1. Little Falls
2. SCC
3. Breck
4. Warroad
Re: Class A tournament seeds
Yep, that's about right.warriors41 wrote:Now that the tournament is jsut about set, how will the seeds end up. I think it will end up like this.
1. Little Falls
2. SCC
3. Breck
4. Warroad
-
- Posts: 66
- Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2007 7:15 pm
-
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Sat Nov 22, 2008 10:41 pm
I think Warroad is a nice choice but one of the 2 losses came to a team in the field. The #2 goes to Cathedral.With STA out of the X this year (thank you Mahtomedi!!), this will be a very interesting A tourney.
But, I would rank Warroad #2 in the seeding given their near-perfect season (only two losses). Here's my guess, but I am somewhat ignornant:
1. Little Falls
2. Warroad
3. Breck
4. Mahtomedi
-
- Posts: 107
- Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2008 11:41 am
-
- Posts: 6848
- Joined: Thu Aug 31, 2006 10:21 pm
Mahtomedi beat Breck, STA and SSP. They have had a couple questionable losses, but they have a very good all around schedule and have wins others don't have. Not sure where I'd put them, but they are definitely a top team and if they don't get seeded I wouldn't want to be the team matched up with them.
My top 4:
1. Little Falls
2. Cathedral
3. Warroad
4. Mahtomedi/Breck toss up
My top 4:
1. Little Falls
2. Cathedral
3. Warroad
4. Mahtomedi/Breck toss up
The numbers 1 to 4 mean nothing except what time you play.
Little Falls, Breck, Warroad, St Cloud Cathedral and Mahtomedi all have a shot at it.
Virginia and Lourdes may sneak in if the coahces try to position themselves.
3A - nope.
But my guess is Little Falls (undefeated), Warroad (only 2 losses, tradition), St Cloud Cathedral (another good record), and Mahtomedi (good wins and beat teh defending champs).
That leaves Breck out of the mix, but so what.
There are 7 good teams. Being one of the four gets you a shot at an easier quarterfinal. But who wants Breck, Lourdes, or Virginia in their first game.
It should be a great tournament.
Little Falls, Breck, Warroad, St Cloud Cathedral and Mahtomedi all have a shot at it.
Virginia and Lourdes may sneak in if the coahces try to position themselves.
3A - nope.
But my guess is Little Falls (undefeated), Warroad (only 2 losses, tradition), St Cloud Cathedral (another good record), and Mahtomedi (good wins and beat teh defending champs).
That leaves Breck out of the mix, but so what.
There are 7 good teams. Being one of the four gets you a shot at an easier quarterfinal. But who wants Breck, Lourdes, or Virginia in their first game.
It should be a great tournament.
I know there are only 4 teams seeded, but let me rank the top 8 in my opinion, and then the top 4 the way they should be seeded.
My opinion
1) Warroad
2) St. Cloud Cathedral
3) Little Falls
4) Breck
5) Mahtomedi
6) Rochester Lourdes
7) Virginia
Hutchinson
What they should be seeded (I think records, and head to head should determine seedings regardless of what other rankings say, and me)
1) Little Falls
2) St. Cloud Cathedral
3) Warroad
4) Breck
Here's how I think they will be seeded tommorow
1) Little Falls
2) Warroad
3) St. Cloud Cathedral
4) Breck
Best first round matchup: Virginia vs Warroad
My opinion
1) Warroad
2) St. Cloud Cathedral
3) Little Falls
4) Breck
5) Mahtomedi
6) Rochester Lourdes
7) Virginia

What they should be seeded (I think records, and head to head should determine seedings regardless of what other rankings say, and me)
1) Little Falls
2) St. Cloud Cathedral
3) Warroad
4) Breck
Here's how I think they will be seeded tommorow
1) Little Falls
2) Warroad
3) St. Cloud Cathedral
4) Breck
Best first round matchup: Virginia vs Warroad
Last edited by HSH1212 on Fri Mar 06, 2009 10:29 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 107
- Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2008 11:41 am
HSH1212 wrote:I know there are only 4 teams seeded, but let me rank the top 8 in my opinion, and then the top 4 the way they should be seeded.
My opinion
1) Warroad
2) St. Cloud Cathedral
3) Little Falls
4) Breck
5) Mahtomedi
6) Rochester Lourdes
7) Virginia
Hutchinson
What they should be seeded (I think records, and head to head should determine seedings regardless of what other rankings say, and me)
1) Little Falls
2) St. Cloud Cathedral
3) Warroad
4) Breck
Here's how I think they will be seeded tommorow
1) Little Falls
2) Warroad
3) St. Cloud Cathedral
4) Warroad
Best first round matchup: Virginia vs Warroad
Better edit your post.
-
- Posts: 666
- Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 1:40 pm
Head to head, records, etc....SCSUHOCKEYFAN15 wrote:SCC beat Warroad and head to head means just about everything. Sorry to say warroad will not be the #2 seed.
The only gimmy quarterfinal game is whoever plays hutch.
....they mean nothing, coaches vote.
1 to 7 leave your own team off....
tabulated and announce the first 4, draw 4 and that's that.
Buit again when you seed 1-4 and not 5-8; the numbers 1-4 mean nothing.
-
- Posts: 107
- Joined: Thu Jan 17, 2008 11:41 am
elliott70 wrote:Head to head, records, etc....SCSUHOCKEYFAN15 wrote:SCC beat Warroad and head to head means just about everything. Sorry to say warroad will not be the #2 seed.
The only gimmy quarterfinal game is whoever plays hutch.
....they mean nothing, coaches vote.
1 to 7 leave your own team off....
tabulated and announce the first 4, draw 4 and that's that.
Buit again when you seed 1-4 and not 5-8; the numbers 1-4 mean nothing.
Ok so what do you think the Coaches are thinking about when they are voting???
-
- Posts: 666
- Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 1:40 pm
Yeah but those head to head meetings, records, etc all influence how a caoch will vote. I would imagine that the SCC would vote Little Falls ahead of Warroad cause Little beat SCC and SCC beat Warroadelliott70 wrote:Head to head, records, etc....SCSUHOCKEYFAN15 wrote:SCC beat Warroad and head to head means just about everything. Sorry to say warroad will not be the #2 seed.
The only gimmy quarterfinal game is whoever plays hutch.
....they mean nothing, coaches vote.
1 to 7 leave your own team off....
tabulated and announce the first 4, draw 4 and that's that.
Buit again when you seed 1-4 and not 5-8; the numbers 1-4 mean nothing.
-
- Posts: 666
- Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 1:40 pm
I don't think that will be possible since both teams should get seeded. I owuld like to see them play sometime in the tournament. Then after taht play Little Falls so Sylvester could play his old teamelliott70 wrote:I hope Warroad gets SCC in the first round game.warriors41 wrote:for my own biased reasons i really hope Warroad gets Hutchinson in the first round.
It would be significantly different this time.
I wouldn't be suprised to see coaches manipulating seeds. For example, the biggest question will be: Who will 2 and 3rd seed? It could be Cathedral, or Warroad. I could see both coaches voting eachother 2-3/7 to hopefully help themselves.elliott70 wrote:Head to head, records, etc....SCSUHOCKEYFAN15 wrote:SCC beat Warroad and head to head means just about everything. Sorry to say warroad will not be the #2 seed.
The only gimmy quarterfinal game is whoever plays hutch.
....they mean nothing, coaches vote.
1 to 7 leave your own team off....
tabulated and announce the first 4, draw 4 and that's that.
Buit again when you seed 1-4 and not 5-8; the numbers 1-4 mean nothing.
-
- Posts: 666
- Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 1:40 pm
I would hope that the coaches have more integrity than to do this. Vote them as they should beHSH1212 wrote:I wouldn't be suprised to see coaches manipulating seeds. For example, the biggest question will be: Who will 2 and 3rd seed? It could be Cathedral, or Warroad. I could see both coaches voting eachother 2-3/7 to hopefully help themselves.elliott70 wrote:Head to head, records, etc....SCSUHOCKEYFAN15 wrote:SCC beat Warroad and head to head means just about everything. Sorry to say warroad will not be the #2 seed.
The only gimmy quarterfinal game is whoever plays hutch.
....they mean nothing, coaches vote.
1 to 7 leave your own team off....
tabulated and announce the first 4, draw 4 and that's that.
Buit again when you seed 1-4 and not 5-8; the numbers 1-4 mean nothing.
-
- Posts: 339
- Joined: Sun Oct 28, 2007 1:44 pm
-
- Posts: 666
- Joined: Sat Mar 01, 2008 1:40 pm
But what should it be?warriors41 wrote:I would hope that the coaches have more integrity than to do this. Vote them as they should beHSH1212 wrote:I wouldn't be suprised to see coaches manipulating seeds. For example, the biggest question will be: Who will 2 and 3rd seed? It could be Cathedral, or Warroad. I could see both coaches voting eachother 2-3/7 to hopefully help themselves.elliott70 wrote: Head to head, records, etc....
....they mean nothing, coaches vote.
1 to 7 leave your own team off....
tabulated and announce the first 4, draw 4 and that's that.
Buit again when you seed 1-4 and not 5-8; the numbers 1-4 mean nothing.
Everything is subjective.
Virginia lost by 1 to Little Falls, so if Little Falls is #1, you cna justify Virginia at #2.
Breck has a good record and played some tough teams earlier on, maybe they are #1.
Warroad has history and two losses to quality teams onthe road. #1?
You can use just about anything to justify it.
As an example, as the coach of a top team, I have played some of these teams, I have played teams that have played all these teams. We had kids out for this game, our goalie played poorly in this game, the D looked weak for this team when I saw them play in December.
You beat me, they beat you, I beat them, you think they are going to do that?
If I am a coach I look at Little Falls and say, undefeated but not a tough game every Tuesday and Thursday, but the first line and Hanowski, but they just got by Alex and we are 3 goals better than Alex... hmm, maybe they are #2 and they beat SCC so SCC is 3. Mahtomedi beat #STA so maybe, but they had some bad games, so I am going with Breck as #1 and then Virginia at #4 because the northern teams have tough games all the time and tehy are a pretty balacned team.
There is no perfect system, because teams change over the season for a variety of reasons.
Personally, right now, I think Warroad is the best A team and Mahtomedi is right behind them. I would not want to play Virginia in the first round because they are playing very well right now.
But Breck, SCC, and Little Falls are great teams. And then you have Lourdes.
So what differecne does it make.
Go win 3 games then we know.