Top Goaltender in the State

nikebauer_07 · Post by **nikebauer_07** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 11:43 am

cooperalls4ever wrote:Nate Hardy - Hermantown (ask Tyler Johnson from Cloquet)

nate hardy is good, but is not one of the best goalies in the state (ask anyone who scored against him last saturday)

RBKRules · Post by **RBKRules** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 12:10 pm

Any goalie that plays against Eastview!!!!!!

NikeBauer14 · Post by **NikeBauer14** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 3:16 pm

What ever happend to Guggenburger? We scrimmaged his team really early this year and he was a wall between the pipes. Not to mention he was yelling and having a good time during play. But I heard he left for Juniors and came back what happened there?

gongshow · Post by **gongshow** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 4:03 pm

NikeBauer14 wrote:What ever happend to Guggenburger? We scrimmaged his team really early this year and he was a wall between the pipes. Not to mention he was yelling and having a good time during play. But I heard he left for Juniors and came back what happened there?

He is playing for richfield now. Had to sit out half the year. He is doing extremely well for them. He is a brick wall...amazing to watch. He stopped 48 of 51 shots against hill murray on saturday and almost upset them (HM won in OT 3-2), despite richfield only having 14 shots the entire game. He has a 1.221 GAA. He plays St.Thomas on thursday... should be a good one. He wasnt in nets last time they played and the cadets won 3-0. Might be a different story now

35Hawksfan · Post by **35Hawksfan** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 4:43 pm

nikebauer_07 wrote:
cooperalls4ever wrote:Nate Hardy - Hermantown (ask Tyler Johnson from Cloquet)
nate hardy is good, but is not one of the best goalies in the state (ask anyone who scored against him last saturday)

Any goalie can have an off game. No one can be on 100% of the time.

gopherhockey33 · Post by **gopherhockey33** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 6:10 pm

is gugs a A draft pick on that web site?

scsucic · Post by **scsucic** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 7:30 pm

Chances are, not a single goaltender on this list qualifies as best goaltender in the state. First of all, these goaltenders are all on good, winning teams, and to have a good team requires a good defense and a good offense which not only keeps the number of shots to a minimum, but can score in close games. The best goaltender out there is probably on a sub .500 team, facing over 30 shots per game. Yes, the best goaltender probably has a losing record (see posts by Johnny_Murphy, HShockeywatcher, and State Champ 97, which are all in a row). Unfortunatley, Ellingson is the only one I have seen in person, and he is darn good. Some of the others I have seen on TV and was left unimpressed. Two things are necessary for being a good goalie -- positioning (training) and quickness (athletic ability). Would the kid from South St. Paul who is now at Duluth have been on that list (this time of year) or the kids from Shakopee who led a sub .500 team to the state tournament? No, they would not, but those may classify as the best goalies from their years.

nikebauer_07 · Post by **nikebauer_07** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 8:11 pm

35Hawksfan wrote:
nikebauer_07 wrote:
cooperalls4ever wrote:Nate Hardy - Hermantown (ask Tyler Johnson from Cloquet)
nate hardy is good, but is not one of the best goalies in the state (ask anyone who scored against him last saturday)
Any goalie can have an off game. No one can be on 100% of the time.

5 goals on hardy - please? does this sound familiar hawksfan??

nikebauer_07 · Post by **nikebauer_07** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 8:15 pm

scsucic wrote:Chances are, not a single goaltender on this list qualifies as best goaltender in the state. First of all, these goaltenders are all on good, winning teams, and to have a good team requires a good defense and a good offense which not only keeps the number of shots to a minimum, but can score in close games. The best goaltender out there is probably on a sub .500 team, facing over 30 shots per game. Yes, the best goaltender probably has a losing record (see posts by Johnny_Murphy, HShockeywatcher, and State Champ 97, which are all in a row). Unfortunatley, Ellingson is the only one I have seen in person, and he is darn good. Some of the others I have seen on TV and was left unimpressed. Two things are necessary for being a good goalie -- positioning (training) and quickness (athletic ability). Would the kid from South St. Paul who is now at Duluth have been on that list (this time of year) or the kids from Shakopee who led a sub .500 team to the state tournament? No, they would not, but those may classify as the best goalies from their years.

Hjelle from the Falls faces on average about 35 shots per game. He has a 93.4% save percentage. thats a pretty darn good goaltender in my book.

Puckhead00 · Post by **Puckhead00** » Mon Feb 05, 2007 8:26 pm

scsucic--finally, another poster who understands and appreciates goaltending.
You have hit the nail right on the head. Good post.

35Hawksfan · Post by **35Hawksfan** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 7:32 am

nikebauer_07 wrote:
35Hawksfan wrote:
nikebauer_07 wrote: nate hardy is good, but is not one of the best goalies in the state (ask anyone who scored against him last saturday)
Any goalie can have an off game. No one can be on 100% of the time.
5 goals on hardy - please? does this sound familiar hawksfan??

Like I said anyone can have an off day, and they still pulled off a Win!

boblee · Post by **boblee** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 8:12 am

I don't care how good his team is. Ellingson is in a class of his own. Hjelle and Yumu are in the next class.

BIAFP · Post by **BIAFP** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 8:14 am

boblee wrote:I don't care how good his team is. Ellingson is in a class of his own. Hjelle and Yumu are in the next class.

You should get back to class

boblee · Post by **boblee** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 8:15 am

I don't have class...either in the form of school, or the way I act.

And it's 8:15. I hope no one is in class.

NightRider · Post by **NightRider** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 9:23 am

Hjellie,Ellingson,Hardy,Yumusakler, Reider "Runnin Bare" Jensen, Jascha Marchuk, just to name a few.

hawkfan70 · Post by **hawkfan70** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 9:30 am

nikebauer_07 wrote:
cooperalls4ever wrote:Nate Hardy - Hermantown (ask Tyler Johnson from Cloquet)
nate hardy is good, but is not one of the best goalies in the state (ask anyone who scored against him last saturday)

last time I checked a W is a W

i don't really care if he is the best goalie or even in the top ten for that matter
as long as he lets in fewer than the guy at the other end of the rink

nikebauer_07 · Post by **nikebauer_07** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 11:43 am

i agree hardy is a good goaltender but im just saying he's not one of the top goaltenders in the state. and yes he did get the win saturday but i just thought it was funny how i predicted he'd give up 5 and everyone was pretty against that.

hawkfan70 · Post by **hawkfan70** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 12:09 pm

nikebauer_07 wrote:i agree hardy is a good goaltender but im just saying he's not one of the top goaltenders in the state. and yes he did get the win saturday but i just thought it was funny how i predicted he'd give up 5 and everyone was pretty against that.

I didn't even think the Hawks were gonna win so it could have been 20-19 and I would still have been OK with it

hawkeyfan · Post by **hawkeyfan** » Tue Feb 06, 2007 12:22 pm

How are we judging a goalie? If its save percentage? Hjelle. If its W/L?then its Hardy. If its goals per game? Ellingson. If its who carries a team to state? then its Reidar Jenson.
I'm sorry all of those in the south and the cities. i haven't seen any of the goalies down there so answer these questions for me.

Most Wins vs. Fewest losses?
Best save%?
Most shutouts?
Fewest goals per game?
Who gets better as the game becomes bigger?

Starshockey9 · Post by **Starshockey9** » Wed Feb 07, 2007 1:30 pm

Has anyone herd of this Mat Hauer kid? HES AMAZEING!!! I went to a North Metro game and he was like a vaccum, he sucked all the pucks up!!!

boblee · Post by **boblee** » Wed Feb 07, 2007 1:40 pm

After last night, how can anyone beg to differ that at this point, it is Reid Ellingson

hockeystud2525 · Post by **hockeystud2525** » Fri Feb 09, 2007 9:52 pm

lefty65 wrote:Matt Ray the freshman from Andover has to be the best freshman right???

but the best in the state has to be Wood from Tartan even if his #'s arent that great

matty ray for sure

gopherhockey33 · Post by **gopherhockey33** » Fri Feb 09, 2007 11:41 pm

k ryan oshea is the best freshman. and the best goalie in the state is between hjelle, yumu, ellingson and howe.

cooperalls4ever · Post by **cooperalls4ever** » Sat Feb 10, 2007 2:39 pm

boblee...after last night 5-0 Stillwater over Cloquet... Ellingson? Really? j/k, Well I think he had 28 saves...that's for those who rubbed off Hardy from Hermantown after he gave up 5 on what 40? saves vs. Hibbing?

Like it was mentioned... goalies have a bad night... any one of the goalies mentioned or those that have save percentages above .92 and/or GAA under 3 are all very good goalies.

I for one remember playing a goalie that ended up D1, the goalie had 45-50 saves and shut us out! His squad only managed about 15-20 shots, but scored 5! The goalie we had in wasn't D1 caliber(had a bad night), but the soph. on the bench was...What stats don't tell you is the quality of saves being made, power play shot/goal attempts, etc. I'm sure we left that goalie with a bruised midsection!

...because we got shots on goal, but never really challenged him.

When it gets to this point, a goalie should have his technique down at 17-18 years old. I truely believe it becomes MENTAL for goaltenders, from HS on. Moreso than other positions.

CrossbarandIn99 · Post by **CrossbarandIn99** » Sat Feb 10, 2007 2:42 pm

gopherhockey33 wrote:k ryan oshea is the best freshman. and the best goalie in the state is between hjelle, yumu, ellingson and howe.

going off the stats these guys have, and taking into consideration the team they have in front of them plus the schedule each guy plays..Id rank them like this..

1. Yumu
2. Hjelle
3. Ellingson
4. Howe

HighSchoolHockeyForums.com

Top Goaltender in the State

Who is it?

how do you rate a goalie