Strike at the U

The Only Forum for Non-Hockey Topics

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)

east hockey
Site Admin
Posts: 7428
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 8:33 pm
Location: Proctor, MN

Post by east hockey »

elliott70 wrote:
packerboy wrote: I do not agree with what he says but defend to the death his right to say it. (I just made that up....well, first I heard that Voltaire said it and then I made it up.)

Voltaire, is he not the father of electricity?????
Voltaire never posted here. He's inconsequential. :)

Lee
PageStat Guy on Bluesky
packerboy
Posts: 5259
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 11:51 am

Post by packerboy »

Lee, thats a real opinion. You think he is the only one who feels that way.

Is it harsh?

Sure but darn it, its not something that hasnt been said before and believe me thare are a lot of people who think the controllers got just what they deserved.

Same with the MLB umpires. A lot of them lost their jobs and people said 'good riddens'.

Not only is hockeygods attitude shared by a lot of a lot of people but insitutions have done exactly as he suggets.

I dont agree with him but ...hey, we now have Johnson grads using 5 dollar words...what could be more surprising. I think we can safely assume that the old Governor didnt learn that word unil he was out of high school.
Last edited by packerboy on Wed Sep 12, 2007 3:50 pm, edited 1 time in total.
elliott70
Posts: 15766
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2004 3:47 pm
Location: Bemidji

Post by elliott70 »

BIAFP wrote:It is really pretty simple.........if you don't like your job, pay, benefits....Quit. If you are really worth more, it shouldn't be to difficult to find a better job. If not, shut up and get to work.
Some people have less options than others.

Some peole like their jobs, but have no other method of obtaining what they are worth other than banning together.

Your life has put you on the other side of the street, but you should still realize that fact.

And Lee and others are right, arrogance in the debate and personal attacks have brought the thread to the point of lock-down, not difference of opinions.
east hockey
Site Admin
Posts: 7428
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 8:33 pm
Location: Proctor, MN

Post by east hockey »

packerboy wrote:Lee, thats a real opinion. You think he is the only one who feels that way.

Is it harsh?

Sure but darn it, its not something that hasnt been said before and believe me thare are a lot of people who think the controllers got just what they deserved.

Same with the MLB umpires. A lot of hem lost their jobs and people said 'good riddens'.

Not only is hockeygods attitude shared by a lot of a lot of people but insitutions have done exactly as he suggets.

I dont agree with him but ...hey, we now have Johnson grads using 5 dollar words...what could be more surprising. I think we can safely assume that the old Governor didnt learn that word unil he was out of high school.
What he said may have been his opinion, but it was a true insult to Chris. I think the Board rules say something about that. It crossed the line. I can't be any clearer than that.

And what happened to PATCO was a disgrace. It was a fate which should have been reserved for a line of work where the employees filling the positions at the time aren't needed. Say, major league baseball.

Lee
PageStat Guy on Bluesky
packerboy
Posts: 5259
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 11:51 am

Post by packerboy »

Lets let ChrisK have the final word.
BIAFP
Posts: 1825
Joined: Thu Feb 13, 2003 3:44 pm

Post by BIAFP »

elliott70 wrote:
BIAFP wrote:It is really pretty simple.........if you don't like your job, pay, benefits....Quit. If you are really worth more, it shouldn't be to difficult to find a better job. If not, shut up and get to work.


Your life has put you on the other side of the street, but you should still realize that fact.

Life doesn't put you anywhere. Hard work, dedication, personal accountability and a good education do.
east hockey
Site Admin
Posts: 7428
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 8:33 pm
Location: Proctor, MN

Post by east hockey »

elliott70 wrote:
BIAFP wrote:It is really pretty simple.........if you don't like your job, pay, benefits....Quit. If you are really worth more, it shouldn't be to difficult to find a better job. If not, shut up and get to work.

And Lee and others are right, arrogance in the debate and personal attacks have brought the thread to the point of lock-down, not difference of opinions.
I just emailed Mitch and asked him to decide. As I told him, I'm too close to the topic to decide.

Lee
PageStat Guy on Bluesky
Can't Never Tried
Posts: 4345
Joined: Thu Sep 14, 2006 3:55 pm

Post by Can't Never Tried »

BIAFP wrote: Life doesn't put you anywhere.
Eventually it put you back in the dirt :wink:

8)
packerboy
Posts: 5259
Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2003 11:51 am

Post by packerboy »

Yup, ashes to ashes, dust to dust.


Ahh, reminds me of Ash Wednesday and the best time of the year.........................Lent.
BIAFP
Posts: 1825
Joined: Thu Feb 13, 2003 3:44 pm

Post by BIAFP »

Can't Never Tried wrote:
BIAFP wrote: Life doesn't put you anywhere.
Eventually it put me back in the dirt :wink:

8)
AngusYoung
Posts: 980
Joined: Sat Jan 04, 2003 4:06 pm

Post by AngusYoung »

elliott70 wrote:
BIAFP wrote:It is really pretty simple.........if you don't like your job, pay, benefits....Quit. If you are really worth more, it shouldn't be to difficult to find a better job. If not, shut up and get to work.
Some people have less options than others.

Some peole like their jobs, but have no other method of obtaining what they are worth other than banning together.

Your life has put you on the other side of the street, but you should still realize that fact.

And Lee and others are right, arrogance in the debate and personal attacks have brought the thread to the point of lock-down, not difference of opinions.
How in the world would you know even what side of the street Bader is on let alone how he got there? You imply he was born with the proverbial golden spoon in his mouth, how would you know? Pretty big leap to assume some decisions made in our lives don't impact our outcomes - it's all in the hands of others I guess.

You guys don't think workers in the private sector have not had to ante up more of their pay to account for rising health care premiums? Wrong - this has impacted all, but I think you would be hard pressed to find private sector annual increases over that 4.25% figure. I know I, as well as employees I supervise, would love to lock in a pay increase of 4.25% with no need for a performance review to validate the increase on. I guess I have to agree with BIAFP on this one - we all have choices and if we are not thrilled with what is being offered for pay at our place of employment, you either need to learn to live with it without bitching or move on to what you consider greener pastures.

AY 8)
Can't Never Tried
Posts: 4345
Joined: Thu Sep 14, 2006 3:55 pm

Post by Can't Never Tried »

BIAFP wrote:
Can't Never Tried wrote:
BIAFP wrote: Life doesn't put you anywhere.
Eventually it puts you back in the dirt :wink:


8)
"puts" Is what is was meant to say!
Funny how a small omission can have such a different effect :lol:

8)
hockeygod
Posts: 225
Joined: Mon Nov 06, 2006 11:07 am

Post by hockeygod »

Yes I may be arrogant...I make my living this way and by taking the opposing opinions. I didn't mean to disrespect Chris in anyway but right or wrong. we hire people to do a job for a certain amount of money, if they come to us and say they want more, I have a right to say no. and the have the right to walk away. I still feel unions don't belong in the public sector and thats why I said send them the down the same road as the air traffic controllers. Money is tight, employees are easy to find, If I was advising the strikers I would have told them to get some free education out of the U to better themselves, so that they can get better jobs, instead of tryiing to get money out of the U after a point when budgets have been set. It was a losing situation for the strikers from the start esspecially when the people who pay the taxes are losing there jobs and taking paycuts. I didn't mean any disrespect and I'm sorry if I hurt anyones feelings but I felt this one sided disscussion merited another point of veiw
Neutron 14
Posts: 5339
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 12:48 pm

Post by Neutron 14 »

east hockey wrote: Barring a suitable answer to the question I posed, Yang bans yin. Now that may not be balance, but I call it justice ala "the meek shall inherit the Bored". And in the words of slappy, ain't a thing can be done about it. Other than whine to Mitch. Good luck. Image

I'm trying to get in mid-season admin form before the season this year.

Lee
In the immortal words of Mel Brooks, "Its good to be King".

Its America. Diverse opinions are good. Right?
The only soft spot I see is the one between my legs
Can't Never Tried
Posts: 4345
Joined: Thu Sep 14, 2006 3:55 pm

Post by Can't Never Tried »

AngusYoung wrote:
elliott70 wrote:
BIAFP wrote:It is really pretty simple.........if you don't like your job, pay, benefits....Quit. If you are really worth more, it shouldn't be to difficult to find a better job. If not, shut up and get to work.
Some people have less options than others.

Some peole like their jobs, but have no other method of obtaining what they are worth other than banning together.

Your life has put you on the other side of the street, but you should still realize that fact.

And Lee and others are right, arrogance in the debate and personal attacks have brought the thread to the point of lock-down, not difference of opinions.
How in the world would you know even what side of the street Bader is on let alone how he got there? You imply he was born with the proverbial golden spoon in his mouth, how would you know? Pretty big leap to assume some decisions made in our lives don't impact our outcomes - it's all in the hands of others I guess.

You guys don't think workers in the private sector have not had to ante up more of their pay to account for rising health care premiums? Wrong - this has impacted all, but I think you would be hard pressed to find private sector annual increases over that 4.25% figure. I know I, as well as employees I supervise, would love to lock in a pay increase of 4.25% with no need for a performance review to validate the increase on. I guess I have to agree with BIAFP on this one - we all have choices and if we are not thrilled with what is being offered for pay at our place of employment, you either need to learn to live with it without bitching or move on to what you consider greener pastures.

AY 8)
4.25% of say 150K is a lot different...then 34K, but I do agree with the performance review issue, you have to work towards set goals that are measurable, and that should be the main basis for pay increases.
You have to be able to say this is why I deserve more and back it up.
But I do believe in cost of living plus inflation...because business(including mine) has no problem raising their rates to offset costs (including labor)...it's just what happens.
But pay needs to keep pace with costs for people to survive and move forward...I mean we want our workers to be happy not just surviving!


8)
elliott70
Posts: 15766
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2004 3:47 pm
Location: Bemidji

Post by elliott70 »

AngusYoung wrote:
elliott70 wrote:
BIAFP wrote:It is really pretty simple.........if you don't like your job, pay, benefits....Quit. If you are really worth more, it shouldn't be to difficult to find a better job. If not, shut up and get to work.
Some people have less options than others.

Some peole like their jobs, but have no other method of obtaining what they are worth other than banning together.

Your life has put you on the other side of the street, but you should still realize that fact.

And Lee and others are right, arrogance in the debate and personal attacks have brought the thread to the point of lock-down, not difference of opinions.
How in the world would you know even what side of the street Bader is on let alone how he got there? You imply he was born with the proverbial golden spoon in his mouth, how would you know? Pretty big leap to assume some decisions made in our lives don't impact our outcomes - it's all in the hands of others I guess.

You guys don't think workers in the private sector have not had to ante up more of their pay to account for rising health care premiums? Wrong - this has impacted all, but I think you would be hard pressed to find private sector annual increases over that 4.25% figure. I know I, as well as employees I supervise, would love to lock in a pay increase of 4.25% with no need for a performance review to validate the increase on. I guess I have to agree with BIAFP on this one - we all have choices and if we are not thrilled with what is being offered for pay at our place of employment, you either need to learn to live with it without bitching or move on to what you consider greener pastures.

AY 8)
Angus
I know BIAFP. Actually we get along quite well. Actually we believe along the same lines.
BIAFP has worked hard to be where he is at today.

But life put him on the side of management. It was where he was born.
Not with a silver spoon, because very few, if any where BIAFP came from, had that good fortune (or curse).
But his initial exposure to the life of economy and business and labor and union, put him on the side of management.
I know this, he knows this.

And Chris did not come on here to b*tch. Maybe some in unions do. But having the right to strike is how they bargain. It is the law and part of our economy, part of bargaining.
Angus, I have seldom agreed with you, but believe you are smart enough to know that. Just walking away from you remplyment becasue labor and managemtn disagree on a pay schedule is not the way things work.
elliott70
Posts: 15766
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2004 3:47 pm
Location: Bemidji

Post by elliott70 »

hockeygod wrote:Yes I may be arrogant...I make my living this way and by taking the opposing opinions. I didn't mean to disrespect Chris in anyway but right or wrong. we hire people to do a job for a certain amount of money, if they come to us and say they want more, I have a right to say no. and the have the right to walk away. I still feel unions don't belong in the public sector and thats why I said send them the down the same road as the air traffic controllers. Money is tight, employees are easy to find, If I was advising the strikers I would have told them to get some free education out of the U to better themselves, so that they can get better jobs, instead of tryiing to get money out of the U after a point when budgets have been set. It was a losing situation for the strikers from the start esspecially when the people who pay the taxes are losing there jobs and taking paycuts. I didn't mean any disrespect and I'm sorry if I hurt anyones feelings but I felt this one sided disscussion merited another point of veiw
Very nicely stated and puts us back on course.
Govs93
Posts: 4367
Joined: Wed Jun 07, 2006 10:57 am
Location: Formerly Eastside - now Wayzata area

Post by Govs93 »

AngusYoung wrote:
elliott70 wrote:
BIAFP wrote:It is really pretty simple.........if you don't like your job, pay, benefits....Quit. If you are really worth more, it shouldn't be to difficult to find a better job. If not, shut up and get to work.
Some people have less options than others.

Some peole like their jobs, but have no other method of obtaining what they are worth other than banning together.

Your life has put you on the other side of the street, but you should still realize that fact.

And Lee and others are right, arrogance in the debate and personal attacks have brought the thread to the point of lock-down, not difference of opinions.
How in the world would you know even what side of the street Bader is on let alone how he got there? You imply he was born with the proverbial golden spoon in his mouth, how would you know? Pretty big leap to assume some decisions made in our lives don't impact our outcomes - it's all in the hands of others I guess.

You guys don't think workers in the private sector have not had to ante up more of their pay to account for rising health care premiums? Wrong - this has impacted all, but I think you would be hard pressed to find private sector annual increases over that 4.25% figure. I know I, as well as employees I supervise, would love to lock in a pay increase of 4.25% with no need for a performance review to validate the increase on. I guess I have to agree with BIAFP on this one - we all have choices and if we are not thrilled with what is being offered for pay at our place of employment, you either need to learn to live with it without bitching or move on to what you consider greener pastures.

AY 8)
I don't know the ins-and-outs of their negotiation, but it is that... a negotiation. I would doubt that AFSCME would expect to actually get 4.25%, but I believe that the U is offering 1% - 1.25% increase (based on this proposal). If you would jump at 4.25%, I would imagine you would probably be just as apt to balk at 1%.

And this statement is ridiculous:
AngusYoung wrote:we all have choices and if we are not thrilled with what is being offered for pay at our place of employment, you either need to learn to live with it without bitching or move on to what you consider greener pastures.
Why is that? You certainly have that option, but why would anybody need to do that? People take positions for reasons other than money - maybe not you - but it's commonplace, and to suggest that people stop "bitching" over pay, when there are many other reasons they have they jobs they do, is - to me - another naive and arrogant statement.
Can't Never Tried
Posts: 4345
Joined: Thu Sep 14, 2006 3:55 pm

Post by Can't Never Tried »

packerboy wrote:Yup, ashes to ashes, dust to dust.


Ahh, reminds me of Ash Wednesday and the best time of the year.........................Lent.
Oh no!! not already.... :o
Govs start the week 2 football thread quick!!...we need a distraction!

8)
Govs93
Posts: 4367
Joined: Wed Jun 07, 2006 10:57 am
Location: Formerly Eastside - now Wayzata area

Post by Govs93 »

Can't Never Tried wrote:
packerboy wrote:Yup, ashes to ashes, dust to dust.


Ahh, reminds me of Ash Wednesday and the best time of the year.........................Lent.
Oh no!! not already.... :o
Govs start the week 2 football thread quick!!...we need a distraction!

8)
I managed to steer clear of the Lent thread (you can check... you won't find me). I'm probably going to hell for it, but you guys are way too creative for me and there's no way I could keep up.

Besides, nothing rhymes with Governor.
Can't Never Tried
Posts: 4345
Joined: Thu Sep 14, 2006 3:55 pm

Post by Can't Never Tried »

Govs93 wrote:I managed to steer clear of the Lent thread (you can check... you won't find me). I'm probably going to hell for it, but you guys are way too creative for me and there's no way I could keep up.

Besides, nothing rhymes with Governor.
Bong is pretty close :shock: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:


8)
Knowlzee
Posts: 325
Joined: Thu Jun 15, 2006 8:36 am

Sometimes work gets in the way

Post by Knowlzee »

Out working a private sector, non-union job, for the maximum compensation that the free market will bear,.......and I missed all the fun.

The highlight was,....when evidently no additional arguments could be made,....and the threat was made to ban the poster, or lock the thread. :)

Most everyone probably wishes the best for ChrisK on a personal basis. By his posts, he appears to be a wonderful guy and certainly a top contributor to the board, but.......do we all need to support and agree with the tactics and principals of unions and collective bargaining? Aren't we often faced with the same tactic of personal association regularly by the Teachers Union when they want us to vote to pass a levy. It's not support them for ChrisK, but......."do it for the kids". Are we ever going to figure that out?

Unions have finacially stressed every private industry they have been involved with. The main problem with government unions is the government will not go bankrupt,.....they will simply take more from the people in the form of increased taxes, fines, and fees. When does it end?
Can't Never Tried
Posts: 4345
Joined: Thu Sep 14, 2006 3:55 pm

Post by Can't Never Tried »

Knowlzee...IDK I'm private sector as well but a 1% offer?? that's what .16¢/hr on an average 34K/yr that's a whole $6.40/week and that does not come close to making up the rise in cost's over the last year.
So I'm not saying we should all just jump on board because some say we like Chris.. I don't even have a clue who he is...
My thoughts are that let's hold the whole U system at that then.. not just those that are doing jobs that some would say are less meaningful...I mean they all work for the same employer...right? Us!

It's a tough deal..... no one want's to pay more but we all want the same or better service.





8)
east hockey
Site Admin
Posts: 7428
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 8:33 pm
Location: Proctor, MN

Re: Sometimes work gets in the way

Post by east hockey »

Knowlzee wrote: Unions have finacially stressed every private industry they have been involved with.
Wrong.

Unions have made it possible for most of us to enjoy a standard of living which most nations could only dream of. But yeah, let's paint Unions with the broad brush of "bad guy". Easy to do when you don't belong to one, huh?

That "let the market decide" is the same line no doubt used by the Carnagies and Rockefellers and the other robber barons in the late 19th century, when the working man had no recourse. Actually, I think their line was more honest; "Screw our employees. They're lucky they have jobs". Not too far from what some have implied, is it?

Now, I'm not saying that unions don't, on occasion, abuse their power. Anybody can find examples of that. But to make a statement like you did is superficial and lacking in knowlege of the history of labor relations in the United States. Shall we go back to 70-hour work weeks, black lung disease and a myriad of occupational hazards which existed prior to the unionization of the American worker? Or do you just trust management to do the "right thing"? Where exactly is that trust warranted?

Knowlzee, your stance is a classic example of "hey, I don't belong to a union, so they're bad for us". Too bad.

Lee
PageStat Guy on Bluesky
east hockey
Site Admin
Posts: 7428
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 8:33 pm
Location: Proctor, MN

Re: Sometimes work gets in the way

Post by east hockey »

Knowlzee wrote: The main problem with government unions is the government will not go bankrupt,.....they will simply take more from the people in the form of increased taxes, fines, and fees. When does it end?
One more quibble; it is actually possible for a form of government to go bankrupt. It's called insolvency and if you knew about Duluth, you'd know that this was being considered a possibilitiy with the City of Duluth. So it isn't quite so simple as you suggest. There are limits to how much taxes, fines and fees can be raised. So that's where that particular situation would end.

And this was actually the City of Duluth's fault, for not addressing a particular situation back when is was manageable. The mayors and City Councils (in other words, the employer) glossed over the issue until the unfunded liability caused the State of Minnesota to step in and strongly advise that Duluth get a handle on this or face severe consequences.

Lee
PageStat Guy on Bluesky
Post Reply