The Largest Prep Hockey Message Board Community on the Web
https://ushsho.com/forums/
Thats the six so yeah if he's asking for six, they count
My Cloquet has zero. I highly doubt we will, ever. That’s ok. I’m a huge fan of the history, kids, and competing spirit of this franchise regardless of state championships/appearances.
That's what I thought but I was TOLD they all count.
Hill has 3 private school championships and 3 public. So 6 altogether. I'd assume that would put Cretin in the 5's too, although they only have one public, so maybe not.
I don't either. You can count them when you combine schools except when you were once two schools. It does seem unfair to have two chances at a title and count those the same as the rest of the schools that had one.O-townClown wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:06 pmI do remember from about 10 years ago that people from Roseau don't recognize Edina East's as an Edina state championship.
Or if Langenbrunner came back his senior year, that could have been the season.Sparlimb wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 3:19 pmHad Corey Millen not gotten hurt. That was your year...
We're all happy with the final true one class champion. Well most of us. I know Lee's still sore...thestickler07 wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 6:40 pm If we include prep/Catholic/independent school championships I'm pretty sure STAA would have 7.
In terms of counting 'top class' titles I would like to see the Academy win at least 2 AA ships before lopping that bigger and older number in with the new banners.
Selfishly wish MSHSL would go to a one-class 'Sweet Sixteen' to produce a single state champion but I get why it would never happen.
Im on the other side, I count Edina East in with the Edina totals because East was the original Edina school and because they still won three titles with half the kids. I am not sure I agree with the argument that it is unfair that they have two chances when to me it seems like they diluted their talent for a decade. Imagine how many championships they would have won if they had stuck together. It obviously wasn't an option if you are aware of how the number of kids had outgrown the high school space, but if they stuck together there is a chance they would have won another title in the 70's.Sparlimb wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 5:42 pmI don't either. You can count them when you combine schools except when you were once two schools. It does seem unfair to have two chances at a title and count those the same as the rest of the schools that had one.O-townClown wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:06 pmI do remember from about 10 years ago that people from Roseau don't recognize Edina East's as an Edina state championship.
Just like I've seen one or two places where WBL tries to count the Mariner 2nd place finish as a first round win...
I thought West did win a title. And my reasoning was that you couldn't count both. So if East became just Edina, then I'm fine with counting them. But if West won a title, you don't get to add that to the total. Not that anyone cares what I think...green4 wrote: ↑Tue Dec 03, 2019 11:45 amIm on the other side, I count Edina East in with the Edina totals because East was the original Edina school and because they still won three titles with half the kids. I am not sure I agree with the argument that it is unfair that they have two chances when to me it seems like they diluted their talent for a decade. Imagine how many championships they would have won if they had stuck together. It obviously wasn't an option if you are aware of how the number of kids had outgrown the high school space, but if they stuck together there is a chance they would have won another title in the 70's.Sparlimb wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 5:42 pmI don't either. You can count them when you combine schools except when you were once two schools. It does seem unfair to have two chances at a title and count those the same as the rest of the schools that had one.O-townClown wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:06 pm
I do remember from about 10 years ago that people from Roseau don't recognize Edina East's as an Edina state championship.
Just like I've seen one or two places where WBL tries to count the Mariner 2nd place finish as a first round win...
If West ever won a state title I think I would have a different opinion because they were the pop up school.
Sparlimb wrote: ↑Tue Dec 03, 2019 11:47 amI thought West did win a title. And my reasoning was that you couldn't count both. So if East became just Edina, then I'm fine with counting them. But if West won a title, you don't get to add that to the total. Not that anyone cares what I think...green4 wrote: ↑Tue Dec 03, 2019 11:45 amIm on the other side, I count Edina East in with the Edina totals because East was the original Edina school and because they still won three titles with half the kids. I am not sure I agree with the argument that it is unfair that they have two chances when to me it seems like they diluted their talent for a decade. Imagine how many championships they would have won if they had stuck together. It obviously wasn't an option if you are aware of how the number of kids had outgrown the high school space, but if they stuck together there is a chance they would have won another title in the 70's.Sparlimb wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 5:42 pm
I don't either. You can count them when you combine schools except when you were once two schools. It does seem unfair to have two chances at a title and count those the same as the rest of the schools that had one.
Just like I've seen one or two places where WBL tries to count the Mariner 2nd place finish as a first round win...
If West ever won a state title I think I would have a different opinion because they were the pop up school.
Excuse me, but Roseville youth hockey used to be pretty dominate in the 60's, 70's and 80's but by the time they got to High School, they split up between Ramsey, Kellogg, and HM. Maybe they would have won a lot of state titles if they stuck together and had a school big enough for all of them.green4 wrote: ↑Tue Dec 03, 2019 11:45 amIm on the other side, I count Edina East in with the Edina totals because East was the original Edina school and because they still won three titles with half the kids. I am not sure I agree with the argument that it is unfair that they have two chances when to me it seems like they diluted their talent for a decade. Imagine how many championships they would have won if they had stuck together. It obviously wasn't an option if you are aware of how the number of kids had outgrown the high school space, but if they stuck together there is a chance they would have won another title in the 70's.Sparlimb wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 5:42 pmI don't either. You can count them when you combine schools except when you were once two schools. It does seem unfair to have two chances at a title and count those the same as the rest of the schools that had one.O-townClown wrote: ↑Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:06 pm
I do remember from about 10 years ago that people from Roseau don't recognize Edina East's as an Edina state championship.
Just like I've seen one or two places where WBL tries to count the Mariner 2nd place finish as a first round win...
If West ever won a state title I think I would have a different opinion because they were the pop up school.
If Edina East’s titles count towards Edina’s total, then I’m lumping the Bloomington schools together. +1 added to the total for Jefferson/Kennedy7TIMECHAMPS wrote: ↑Tue Dec 03, 2019 12:40 pm To me the Edina East titles count. There is no way class A or private school does though.
