Page 2 of 2

Posted: Mon Jul 01, 2013 7:08 pm
by OnFrozenPond
nobama wrote:some nice players NOT 1 is on any NHL GM's must have list :idea:
That's not really the point though is it?

Posted: Mon Jul 01, 2013 7:28 pm
by longdistancespectator8
nobama wrote:some nice players NOT 1 is on any NHL GM's must have list :idea:

I'm pretty confident Martin St. Louis would make a few must have lists.

Posted: Mon Jul 01, 2013 8:29 pm
by DubCHAGuy
nobama wrote:some nice players NOT 1 is on any NHL GM's must have list :idea:
I think the point that was plenty of good players aren't high picks or don't even get drafted at all. And plenty (actually, the majority) of draft picks never see the NHL.

Also, you don't think the Vezina winner, the runner up, the NHL leading scorer, or the D-man who ran Canada's power play during their 2010 gold medal run would attract any interest from GM's? :-k

Posted: Tue Jul 02, 2013 10:12 am
by DrGaf
nobama wrote:some nice players NOT 1 is on any NHL GM's must have list :idea:
Really? ... REALLY?? ... reeeeally???

Posted: Tue Jul 02, 2013 10:14 am
by Bluewhitefan
nobama wrote:some nice players NOT 1 is on any NHL GM's must have list :idea:
Complete Troll post.

Posted: Tue Jul 02, 2013 12:02 pm
by Bonin2121
nobama wrote:some nice players NOT 1 is on any NHL GM's must have list :idea:
These guys should just quit playing.

PENGUINS

Posted: Tue Jul 02, 2013 1:53 pm
by Tenoverpar
I'm just looking forward to Crosby and Malkin retiring someday and the new down the middle for the Penguins is "dirty" Jake Guentzel and
"easy" Teddy Bleuger (MSU/SSM)

Re: PENGUINS

Posted: Tue Jul 02, 2013 3:26 pm
by northwoods oldtimer
Tenoverpar wrote:I'm just looking forward to Crosby and Malkin retiring someday and the new down the middle for the Penguins is "dirty" Jake Guentzel and
"easy" Teddy Bleuger (MSU/SSM)
Uff da!

Guentzel

Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 2:36 pm
by Granttenn
Speaking of Guentzel. My Hill Murray heart breaks thinking of what could have been had not Guentzel (3rd Rd) and Blake Heinrich (5th Rd) left for the USHL for their Sr years. State tourney runner-up? I don't think so. Imagine the that sweet 1st line from 2012 still intact (Jr) Guentzel - (Jr) Lavalle - (So) Brown with (Jr) Heinrich breaking the puck out of the zone and floating on the line like he did.. Add Slattery in there somewhere, like taking Charlie Sampair's role and I think the boys could have taken the big one home.. Is Hill the only team recently to have two top 5 round picks from the same class & have them both leave for Sr year besides.

The bigger point is that the days of the dynasty are largely gone unless you have incredible balance because the cream will be sifted off by the USHL or the U18 development camp etc. It really does change the dynamics for those of us who love MN High School hockey above all other forms.

The draft does provide a little relief in the middle of the summer blues and the Elite League is coming up in a couple of months but anybody taiking about the 2013-14 season yet. Top 5 teams? Are Hurley and Mahlmquist sticking around?

Speaking of Hill Murray, anybody know much about this 6'2" Soph (to be) Goalie as a replacement for Dugas. I see he was one of only 3 MN HS (active) G's to be drafted by the USHL (along with Ahrenz and Driscoll) - so that says a lot.. I guess he was originally from Hudson.

-

Re: Guentzel

Posted: Thu Jul 04, 2013 7:12 pm
by Bonin2121
Granttenn wrote:My Hill Murray heart breaks
My (east metro public school) heart breaks thinking of what could have been if (pick Hill player) had stuck around. You poor folks losing two players. You should feel lucky that your team is in the running every year. :wink:

Posted: Fri Jul 05, 2013 7:58 am
by Tigers33
Am I reading this correctly that a private school backer is complaining about kids leaving leaving school early. Wondering all the what it's, huh?

Next thing they'll do is complain about kids they couldn't get and start wondering what if...

Re: Guentzel

Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 1:34 pm
by karl(east)
Granttenn wrote:Speaking of Guentzel. My Hill Murray heart breaks thinking of what could have been had not Guentzel (3rd Rd) and Blake Heinrich (5th Rd) left for the USHL for their Sr years. State tourney runner-up? I don't think so. Imagine the that sweet 1st line from 2012 still intact (Jr) Guentzel - (Jr) Lavalle - (So) Brown with (Jr) Heinrich breaking the puck out of the zone and floating on the line like he did.. Add Slattery in there somewhere, like taking Charlie Sampair's role and I think the boys could have taken the big one home.. Is Hill the only team recently to have two top 5 round picks from the same class & have them both leave for Sr year besides.

The bigger point is that the days of the dynasty are largely gone unless you have incredible balance because the cream will be sifted off by the USHL or the U18 development camp etc. It really does change the dynamics for those of us who love MN High School hockey above all other forms.

The draft does provide a little relief in the middle of the summer blues and the Elite League is coming up in a couple of months but anybody taiking about the 2013-14 season yet. Top 5 teams? Are Hurley and Mahlmquist sticking around?

Speaking of Hill Murray, anybody know much about this 6'2" Soph (to be) Goalie as a replacement for Dugas. I see he was one of only 3 MN HS (active) G's to be drafted by the USHL (along with Ahrenz and Driscoll) - so that says a lot.. I guess he was originally from Hudson.

-
To the first point--they're probably the first team in recent memory to have two draft picks leave in the same year, though I'm guessing Holy Angels had a year or two like that in the early 00s, and plenty of teams recently have had more than one draft pick. (2011 Edina and EP and Holy Angels if you count early departures, 2010 Minnetonka, Edina and maybe more in 2009...) Having multiple draft picks is no guarantee of a title, though obviously it would have helped Hill's odds last season.

As for there not being any more dynasties, I'm not at all convinced. At the section level, we've had a bunch recently: Edina, Hill, East, Moorhead, Blaine going back a couple of years. They're all deep teams that were well-positioned to weather early departures, which all of them suffered. At the state championship level dynasties may be more rare than they used to be, but one (Holy Angels, 02-05) did it by getting a lot out of a bunch of young players who went on to leave early. It can be done. And Edina had the talent to build a dynasty in the late 00s, but they didn't deliver. Looking at their youth program, they might be on the verge of another run, too. There's more turnover now than there was in the days of, say, the Jefferson dynasty, but teams can still go on a run if they have enough good players feeding in.

Hard to do much in the way of preseason rankings when we're still waiting to see who stays and who goes and who transfers. I won't be bothering with that for a while yet.

Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 3:26 pm
by Slap Shot
I imagine Tonka would have done much better had Lettieri stayed and I am sure there are other schools that could say the same thing. Tonka lost another star for this season, but you can't dwell on it...

Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 3:32 pm
by mulefarm
What star did Tonka loose this year?

Tonka

Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 5:58 pm
by blueblood
He is referring to Jack Ramsey.

Re: Guentzel

Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 6:27 pm
by DubCHAGuy
karl(east) wrote:
Granttenn wrote:Speaking of Guentzel. My Hill Murray heart breaks thinking of what could have been had not Guentzel (3rd Rd) and Blake Heinrich (5th Rd) left for the USHL for their Sr years. State tourney runner-up? I don't think so. Imagine the that sweet 1st line from 2012 still intact (Jr) Guentzel - (Jr) Lavalle - (So) Brown with (Jr) Heinrich breaking the puck out of the zone and floating on the line like he did.. Add Slattery in there somewhere, like taking Charlie Sampair's role and I think the boys could have taken the big one home.. Is Hill the only team recently to have two top 5 round picks from the same class & have them both leave for Sr year besides.

The bigger point is that the days of the dynasty are largely gone unless you have incredible balance because the cream will be sifted off by the USHL or the U18 development camp etc. It really does change the dynamics for those of us who love MN High School hockey above all other forms.

The draft does provide a little relief in the middle of the summer blues and the Elite League is coming up in a couple of months but anybody taiking about the 2013-14 season yet. Top 5 teams? Are Hurley and Mahlmquist sticking around?

Speaking of Hill Murray, anybody know much about this 6'2" Soph (to be) Goalie as a replacement for Dugas. I see he was one of only 3 MN HS (active) G's to be drafted by the USHL (along with Ahrenz and Driscoll) - so that says a lot.. I guess he was originally from Hudson.

-
To the first point--they're probably the first team in recent memory to have two draft picks leave in the same year.


Hill 2007- Mike Hoeffel, Nick Larson, and Nick Pryor. Pioneers can't catch a break :wink:

Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 9:50 pm
by Pioneerprideguy
What ever happened to Prior? I know he verbally committed to the Badgers early then left HM. Never heard about him after that.

Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 9:13 am
by karl(east)
Pioneerprideguy wrote:What ever happened to Prior? I know he verbally committed to the Badgers early then left HM. Never heard about him after that.
He wound up at Maine, where it looks like he never really became much of a regular: http://www.hockeydb.com/ihdb/stats/pdis ... pid=113848

Also, wasn't Nick Larson a Mr. Hockey finalist? Pretty sure he didn't leave early.

Posted: Mon Jul 08, 2013 1:35 pm
by Pioneerprideguy
Thanks Karl.

Posted: Tue Jul 09, 2013 2:41 pm
by minnscout
Although they left after before Junior season Benilde lost Collins and Glover whom have decent chance to be drafted in top 5 rounds next year.