HighSchoolHockeyForums.com

hockeya1a wrote:Just curious, but in the article it states that Roseaus team had the Student Manager dress as a goalie because they need to have 2 dressed for the game.

http://www.startribune.com/sports/preps/15822897.html


But if she is not on the Roster can she even be on the bench?
Here is a list of there Roster from the MSHSL

Would that not be an Illegal player???

I would think they would have to take someone off there roster!


2 Mary Loken W 11
4 Amanda Monkman D 10
5 Toni Crosson W 11
6 Dawn Comstock D 11
7 Hannah Anderson D 11
8 Dani Janzen W 12
9 Breanna Janzen D 11
10 Kylie Lane C 11
11 Rachel Landman D 9
12 Amy Olson C 10
14 Paige Moser W 10
15 Abby Ness W 9
17 Punky Sunsdahl W 10
30 Chelsey Froseth G 11

Rosters sent to MSHSL by State participants may be different than the roster that the MSHSL recieved at the start of the year.
A State participant team may add, up to 20 roster spots, some JV players or "a student manager" to the fianl State roster. The adding of players provides experience to the JV kids at the big dance!
The roster has to include 2 goalies! That means 18 skaters are allowed.

Last year, Rochester Mayo, made the trip to St. Paul. All year, one goalie played, their backup goalie was the student manager. The student manager had to be placed on the roster of 20, because of the need for 2 goalies on the roster. That displaced one skater from playing at state, I know, because that skater was my 8th grade daughter...
I hope this clarifies the ruling...

HOCKEYPUCK2 wrote: Now I am playing catch up here. Now, who is Abby Williams father, GOCARDS1 or cardswinagain?

On the Birth Certificate or in the DNA? I am just the crazy uncle.

I can not wait to finish this and silence all. GO CARDS!!

cardswinagain wrote:

HOCKEYPUCK2 wrote: Now I am playing catch up here. Now, who is Abby Williams father, GOCARDS1 or cardswinagain?

On the Birth Certificate or in the DNA? I am just the crazy uncle.

I can not wait to finish this and silence all. GO CARDS!!

Silence all the cheering Roseau fans after the game...

Good luck to Alex!
Should be a great game!

Looking at both teams and checking out their common opponents, this just has the feel of a 1 goal game, like 2-1. Let see here ... ahhh ... the coin came up heads, so I'll go with Roseau!

I've seen both teams play once (against GRG), and I'm going to have to give the nod to Roseau. It'll probably be a one-goal affair, and an overtime game wouldn't surprise me at all.
Plus, I've gotta stick to my Northern Pride!

leave us simple city folk out of this hp2

cardswinagain wrote:

HOCKEYPUCK2 wrote: Now I am playing catch up here. Now, who is Abby Williams father, GOCARDS1 or cardswinagain?

On the Birth Certificate or in the DNA? I am just the crazy uncle.

I can not wait to finish this and silence all. GO CARDS!!

Ah hah! I knew 'cardswinagain' wasn't from Alex. I know her parents have way more class than that. We don't have anyone on the team that is that obnoxious. I'm sure if Abby read what he wrote she would be embarrassed by all the attention.

pondhockey wrote:

cardswinagain wrote:

HOCKEYPUCK2 wrote: Now I am playing catch up here. Now, who is Abby Williams father, GOCARDS1 or cardswinagain?

On the Birth Certificate or in the DNA? I am just the crazy uncle.

I can not wait to finish this and silence all. GO CARDS!!

Ah hah! I knew 'cardswinagain' wasn't from Alex. I know her parents have way more class than that. We don't have anyone on the team that is that obnoxious. I'm sure if Abby read what he wrote she would be embarrassed by all the attention.

Trying to disown the dysfunctional. I am not buying it. I suppose GOCARDS1 is not from Alex either. Who is more obnoxious GOCARDS1, cardswinagain, or ALEX fans in general?

Roseau 3 Alex 2

WOW I am so shocked, some people are more afraid of a back up goalie that can not stand on the ice with the pads on than the reg. players. It almost sounds like IF roseau wins they need to put a @ ** after it.

gohome wrote:WOW I am so shocked, some people are more afraid of a back up goalie that can not stand on the ice with the pads on than the reg. players. It almost sounds like IF roseau wins they need to put a @ ** after it.

I don't think that is the case, just some confusion about the issues of the official roster and the back up goalie requirement. Until the STRIB article yesterday, most fans were probably not aware of it.

Getting back to the game at hand, I haven't seen Roseau play this year and knowing that the first game was a tie, I've got to go with Alex 2 to 1 in OT.

HOCKEYPUCK2 wrote:I like how GOCARDS constantly edits his posts. That is someone who speaks before they think. Come on GOCARDS, you are making the citiots look smart.

he's a she

Final 2 - 1 Alex over Roseau. Go Cards, good luck Saturday