Page 2 of 2
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 5:01 pm
by ehshockey
[.[/quote]
A fluke you say? were you even at the game? Benilde out played them, plain and simple.
[/quote]
I was at the game and I have seen Edina a lot this season and know that Edina is a better team then Benilde. I think when Edina plays their best (wich they did not against Benilde) they are the best team in the state.
1. Edina
2. Roseau
3. Benilde
4. Minnetonka
5. Hill-Murray
6. Hopkins
7. Centennial
8. Eden Prairie
9. Jefferson
10.WBL
Don't shoot the messenger
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 11:17 pm
by who_b_dat
PS2 ran some calculations tonight and apparently came up with:
1) St. Thomas Academy
2) Hill Murray
3) Minnetonka
4) Edina
5) Benilde St Margaret
6) Roseau
7) Centennial
8 Moorhead
9) Blaine
10) Duluth East
For a complete list check out
http://www.minnhock.com/pagestat.htm
Re: Don't shoot the messenger
Posted: Tue Jan 08, 2008 2:16 am
by Circles
who_b_dat wrote:PS2 ran some calculations tonight and apparently came up with:
1) St. Thomas Academy
2) Hill Murray
3) Minnetonka
4) Edina
5) Benilde St Margaret
6) Roseau
7) Centennial
8 Moorhead
9) Blaine
10) Duluth East
For a complete list check out
http://www.minnhock.com/pagestat.htm
Hopkins beats Minnetonka, yet only moves up 3.5 spots, from 25 to tied for 21(still behind Woodbury).
Meanwhile Minnetonka falls only 1 spot, from 2 to 3.
Hmmm........that doesn't make much sense. Seems like a #25 team beating a #2 team should have a LITTLE more impact, especially with only a 13 game picture from which to judge these teams.
Posted: Tue Jan 08, 2008 3:24 am
by Fargo
Lopresti wrote:1-Roseau: undefeated, won it last year
2-Edina: Lost to Benilde fair and square but Hockeyfan43 said it was a fluke so I guess that means they won
3-Mahdomedi: Hill should be here but lost to Tartan and Zephyrs beat Tartan
4-Wayzata: Lost 3 players to BSM who beat Edina (although fluky?)
5-BSM: Wayzata players aren't good enough
6-Minnetonka: Although losing to Hopkins, Parrish4Pres. says they should have one so that's like a win
7-Lakeville North: beat Kennedy 7-1 where Jefferson only beat them 6-1
8-Hopkins: undefeated and beat Tonka but I guess should have lost...?
9-Mankato West: somebody from south needs to be here, right?
10-Kennedy: although winless and outscored 14 to 85, they've been screwed by the refs all year
a poll with as much logic as any
