What Do You Do

Discussion of Minnesota Youth Hockey

Moderators: Mitch Hawker, east hockey, karl(east)

Post Reply
OreoSlaper09
Posts: 24
Joined: Sat Aug 30, 2008 11:27 pm

What Do You Do

Post by OreoSlaper09 »

So last weekend I was down in Faribault watching the championship game for district 4 bantam A. It was between the AWAY team Faribault and The HOME team Albert Lea. So they turn off the lights and have the spotlight going. No music no exciting announcer, just the spotlight. So They Announce the HOME team Albert Lea First. Then the announce the AWAY Faribault team. the spotlight starts spinning, the music blaring, the announcer gets all excited and says "NOW FOR THE HOMETOWN TEAM, THE FARIBAULT FALCONS." In districts the point is to not FAVOR THE HOME TOWN. Am I right?? Something should be done. Please post some thoughts on what should happen!
defense
Posts: 1637
Joined: Thu Dec 06, 2007 8:20 pm
Location: right here

Re: What Do You Do

Post by defense »

OreoSlaper09 wrote:So last weekend I was down in Faribault watching the championship game for district 4 bantam A. It was between the AWAY team Faribault and The HOME team Albert Lea. So they turn off the lights and have the spotlight going. No music no exciting announcer, just the spotlight. So They Announce the HOME team Albert Lea First. Then the announce the AWAY Faribault team. the spotlight starts spinning, the music blaring, the announcer gets all excited and says "NOW FOR THE HOMETOWN TEAM, THE FARIBAULT FALCONS." In districts the point is to not FAVOR THE HOME TOWN. Am I right?? Something should be done. Please post some thoughts on what should happen!
Agree and don't agree. Home team, fine, let them have fun, but it is districts.........but they ARE hosting.... comes down to sportsmanship and respect...
I'll throw this out there: when a high school team hosts a sectional tournement game, do they keep it even on the anouncements????
Security Coach
Posts: 6
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2009 11:18 pm

Post by Security Coach »

I was also watching that game and didnt like what I saw! Spoke to other people and they were not very fond of it either!
WayOutWest
Posts: 611
Joined: Fri Feb 02, 2007 11:45 am

Re: What Do You Do

Post by WayOutWest »

defense wrote:
OreoSlaper09 wrote:So last weekend I was down in Faribault watching the championship game for district 4 bantam A. It was between the AWAY team Faribault and The HOME team Albert Lea. So they turn off the lights and have the spotlight going. No music no exciting announcer, just the spotlight. So They Announce the HOME team Albert Lea First. Then the announce the AWAY Faribault team. the spotlight starts spinning, the music blaring, the announcer gets all excited and says "NOW FOR THE HOMETOWN TEAM, THE FARIBAULT FALCONS." In districts the point is to not FAVOR THE HOME TOWN. Am I right?? Something should be done. Please post some thoughts on what should happen!
Agree and don't agree. Home team, fine, let them have fun, but it is districts.........but they ARE hosting.... comes down to sportsmanship and respect...
I'll throw this out there: when a high school team hosts a sectional tournement game, do they keep it even on the anouncements????
In high school, the first game of sections is typically hosted by the higher ranked team. And no, they don't keep the announcements even.
That first home game is earned, by record, and is purposely placed at the better team's rink in order to provide them that advantage.
After that, section games go to neutral sites, in order to avoid the home ice advantage.
I think it works fine. It's a small advantage for the team that earned the better record thoughout the season. That sounds perfectly fair to me.
muckandgrind
Posts: 1566
Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2008 10:48 am

Re: What Do You Do

Post by muckandgrind »

WayOutWest wrote:
defense wrote:
OreoSlaper09 wrote:So last weekend I was down in Faribault watching the championship game for district 4 bantam A. It was between the AWAY team Faribault and The HOME team Albert Lea. So they turn off the lights and have the spotlight going. No music no exciting announcer, just the spotlight. So They Announce the HOME team Albert Lea First. Then the announce the AWAY Faribault team. the spotlight starts spinning, the music blaring, the announcer gets all excited and says "NOW FOR THE HOMETOWN TEAM, THE FARIBAULT FALCONS." In districts the point is to not FAVOR THE HOME TOWN. Am I right?? Something should be done. Please post some thoughts on what should happen!
Agree and don't agree. Home team, fine, let them have fun, but it is districts.........but they ARE hosting.... comes down to sportsmanship and respect...
I'll throw this out there: when a high school team hosts a sectional tournement game, do they keep it even on the anouncements????
In high school, the first game of sections is typically hosted by the higher ranked team. And no, they don't keep the announcements even.
That first home game is earned, by record, and is purposely placed at the better team's rink in order to provide them that advantage.
After that, section games go to neutral sites, in order to avoid the home ice advantage.
I think it works fine. It's a small advantage for the team that earned the better record thoughout the season. That sounds perfectly fair to me.
Problem is, that this isn't high school, it's Bantams. Albert Lea never EARNED the right to host this District tournament, they were CHOSEN.
Security Coach
Posts: 6
Joined: Fri Feb 27, 2009 11:18 pm

Post by Security Coach »

you guys are wrong. faribault held the tournament and albert lea was the home team because they had the better record. if you reread oreoslapers comment it explains it.
Tenoverpar
Posts: 514
Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2008 3:40 pm

Slapper

Post by Tenoverpar »

OSLAP-

Where have you been? How did New Ulm do this year? Are you getting the respect your team deserves?
defense
Posts: 1637
Joined: Thu Dec 06, 2007 8:20 pm
Location: right here

Re: What Do You Do

Post by defense »

WayOutWest wrote:
defense wrote:
OreoSlaper09 wrote:So last weekend I was down in Faribault watching the championship game for district 4 bantam A. It was between the AWAY team Faribault and The HOME team Albert Lea. So they turn off the lights and have the spotlight going. No music no exciting announcer, just the spotlight. So They Announce the HOME team Albert Lea First. Then the announce the AWAY Faribault team. the spotlight starts spinning, the music blaring, the announcer gets all excited and says "NOW FOR THE HOMETOWN TEAM, THE FARIBAULT FALCONS." In districts the point is to not FAVOR THE HOME TOWN. Am I right?? Something should be done. Please post some thoughts on what should happen!
Agree and don't agree. Home team, fine, let them have fun, but it is districts.........but they ARE hosting.... comes down to sportsmanship and respect...
I'll throw this out there: when a high school team hosts a sectional tournement game, do they keep it even on the anouncements????
In high school, the first game of sections is typically hosted by the higher ranked team. And no, they don't keep the announcements even.
That first home game is earned, by record, and is purposely placed at the better team's rink in order to provide them that advantage.
After that, section games go to neutral sites, in order to avoid the home ice advantage.
I think it works fine. It's a small advantage for the team that earned the better record thoughout the season. That sounds perfectly fair to me.
I'd be interested to know how it works out in section 8a then, since they have been rotating sites for semi's and finals between Theif River Falls, East Grand Forks, and Warroad for years. This year it has been in Warroad and I have to assume that the home town...err,,,the team representing the home town high school gets prefferential treatment. I'm not saying it is completely right, but it is still confusing.
WayOutWest
Posts: 611
Joined: Fri Feb 02, 2007 11:45 am

Re: What Do You Do

Post by WayOutWest »

defense wrote:
WayOutWest wrote:
In high school, the first game of sections is typically hosted by the higher ranked team. And no, they don't keep the announcements even.
That first home game is earned, by record, and is purposely placed at the better team's rink in order to provide them that advantage.
After that, section games go to neutral sites, in order to avoid the home ice advantage.
I think it works fine. It's a small advantage for the team that earned the better record thoughout the season. That sounds perfectly fair to me.
I'd be interested to know how it works out in section 8a then, since they have been rotating sites for semi's and finals between Theif River Falls, East Grand Forks, and Warroad for years. This year it has been in Warroad and I have to assume that the home town...err,,,the team representing the home town high school gets prefferential treatment. I'm not saying it is completely right, but it is still confusing.
Oops. :oops: I may have spoken too soon. I was speaking from experience in what I see in section 6AA. Looking at all the brackets, it looks to be pretty inconsistent, actually. Some sections stick with the "first series is played at the high seed rinks" plan, and some throw that right out the window. In 8A, the play-in games look like they were played at the higher seeded team's rinks, but everything beyond that is being played at Warroad.
It appears as though it may be up to the section to decide.
Warroad is the #1 seed in the section, so perhaps that was the deciding factor? Or, does the Warroad arena just have the best seating capacity in that section?
On the surface, it would seem a bit unfair that Warroad could have home games throughout. :roll:
dakotakid
Posts: 71
Joined: Wed Feb 18, 2009 4:28 pm

Post by dakotakid »

It sounds just like the Gophers getting the advantage every year in the final 5 without earning it. I dont hear you Gopher fans complaining about that.
spin-o-rama
Posts: 547
Joined: Wed Jun 06, 2007 2:30 pm

Post by spin-o-rama »

dakotakid wrote:It sounds just like the Gophers getting the advantage every year in the final 5 without earning it. I dont hear you Gopher fans complaining about that.
Are you saying oreoslaper09 is a sue fan?
defense
Posts: 1637
Joined: Thu Dec 06, 2007 8:20 pm
Location: right here

Re: What Do You Do

Post by defense »

WayOutWest wrote:
defense wrote:
WayOutWest wrote:
In high school, the first game of sections is typically hosted by the higher ranked team. And no, they don't keep the announcements even.
That first home game is earned, by record, and is purposely placed at the better team's rink in order to provide them that advantage.
After that, section games go to neutral sites, in order to avoid the home ice advantage.
I think it works fine. It's a small advantage for the team that earned the better record thoughout the season. That sounds perfectly fair to me.
I'd be interested to know how it works out in section 8a then, since they have been rotating sites for semi's and finals between Theif River Falls, East Grand Forks, and Warroad for years. This year it has been in Warroad and I have to assume that the home town...err,,,the team representing the home town high school gets prefferential treatment. I'm not saying it is completely right, but it is still confusing.
Oops. :oops: I may have spoken too soon. I was speaking from experience in what I see in section 6AA. Looking at all the brackets, it looks to be pretty inconsistent, actually. Some sections stick with the "first series is played at the high seed rinks" plan, and some throw that right out the window. In 8A, the play-in games look like they were played at the higher seeded team's rinks, but everything beyond that is being played at Warroad.
It appears as though it may be up to the section to decide.
Warroad is the #1 seed in the section, so perhaps that was the deciding factor? Or, does the Warroad arena just have the best seating capacity in that section?
On the surface, it would seem a bit unfair that Warroad could have home games throughout. :roll:
The way I understand it, section 8a's best rinks are in Warroad, Theif River Falls (wether now at their Little Ralph or before at the Huck), and East Grank Forks and the section tourney rotates between them three regardless of who is the #1 seed.
Post Reply